Skip to product information
1 of 3

Experience Cookie Bliss

PB Supremes

Crafted with Care, Baked to Perfection

Size
Your Product Purchase Options
No available purchase options for this selection.
Deliver Every
Deliver Every

A peanut butter hug in every bite

Our PB Supreme cookie starts with a buttery base of unsalted butter, granulated sugar, and just the right touch of light brown sugar for that perfect chew. We mix in cage-free eggs and pure vanilla extract to bring the dough together, then fold in local favorite Teddie Peanut Butter from Everett — the true star of this cookie. Made with King Arthur flour, a hint of kosher salt, and gentle leaveners, each soft dough ball is hand-scooped and baked to golden brown perfection. Whether you’re treating yourself or sharing with friends, these half-dozen stacks deliver rich, peanut buttery goodness in every chewy bite. Subscribe and save to keep these peanut butter hugs coming regularly

Ingredients: Flour, Butter, Light Brown Sugar, Sugar, Peanut Butter, Egg, Vanilla, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Salt

CONTAINS: WHEAT, MILK, EGGS, & PEANUTS

Customer Reviews

Based on 5 reviews
80%
(4)
20%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
J
Jerry Schey

Were delicious! Yummy!

S
Susan OBrien

Gift recipient loved the cookies!

B
Brian & Steph
Wow!

These peanut butter cookies were delicious. Fantastic flavor and really maintained their soft chewiness.

E
Eleanor Miller
Top Shelf Makes PB Awesome

I am a peanut butter lover and these cookies are supremely delicious.

K
Kathy Q.
Peanut butter Cookies

They are the best !! Full of peanut butter flavor. Brings me back to my childhood. Crisp but soft and moist !!!

Crafted with care, baked to irresistible perfection

Top Shelf Cookies only makes cookies, so we have be good at it. We have developed over 200 recipes in our ten years. Each recipe is carefully balanced, expertly combines high-quality and unique ingredients with well-crafted recipes. Every batch is crafted with care, attention to detail, and a passion for pushing the boundaries of cookie perfection.

Everyone loves Cookies!

  • Handmade

    Our cookies are lovingly handcrafted in small batches using premium ingredients and artisanal techniques. Each bite delivers exceptional flavor and texture, brimming with homemade warmth and comfort.

  • Ingredients You Can Pronounce

    We use only high-quality, recognizable ingredients like rich butter, cage-free eggs, and real chocolate. Our commitment to wholesome ingredients means no artificial additives, just pure cookie goodness in every bite.

  • Fast Shipping

    We bake and ship cookies to order Tuesday through Saturday, typically sending them out the next day. Our careful packaging ensures your treats arrive fresh and ready to enjoy, no matter where you are.

Top Shelf Cookies aren't your typical cookie, so it's no surprise we were founded in a less than typical manner. Heather started making cookies as a superstition and then made it her job. Over ten years later, Heather and her time are still crafting up new recipes with high quality and sometimes unusual ingredients!

Frequently Asked Questions

Top Shelf Cookies

What size cookies are they?

Some cookies are giant and you can't finish them and some cookies are tiny! Our are "just right"

What kind of ingredients do you use?

We use quality ingredients, each of our cookie packs comes with an ingredient label with ingredients you can pronounce and are familiar with!

When do you ship?

We ship Tuesday - Saturday via USPS from our bakery in Boston, MA. Most orders are shipped within 1 business day of being placed

Can I add gift message?

Yes! Indicate that the order is a gift at checkout and leave your message, we'll include a hand written note with your order

What is the shelf life?

We like to see the cookies eaten within 10 days of baking, provided they are stored sealed. If you get them and you want to make them last, they freeze beautifully

How should I store these?

Always keep them wrapped and closed up! If you are planning to finish them in the next couple days, room temperature is perfect, if you have more cookies than you can handle right now - keep them in the freezer. They will defrost in no time!

Do you have a shop?

Yes! Our shop is our kitchen with the door open, so we have a lot of our favorites and we have some experimental flavors!